.
Feedback

Montgomery County Bag Tax Nets $154,000 in January

The bag tax could net up to $1.8 million in 2012, according to The Gazette.

Montgomery County’s hotly-contested bag tax netted $154,000 in its initial month, according to a report by The Gazette.

Approximately 3.8 million bags were taxed, but County Executive Isiah Leggett (D) told The Gazette the county needs more data to understand whether the tax is meeting its goals.

"We need more data beyond the first month, maybe a few months to a year," Leggett told The Gazette. "People are still getting adjusted to it."

According to the report, January’s bag tax revenue sets the county on pace to receive $1.8 million in 2012 if the first month’s numbers are maintained.

, and the county expected to earn up to $1.5 million from the tax in the first year. This money will go to the Water Quality Protection Fund (WQPF), which covers stormwater management, watershed restoration and litter clean-up.

“The executive has said repeatedly that the county does not view the tax as a revenue stream for the Water Quality Protection Charge fund—where the money will go—but rather a program to curtail waste and encourage the use of reusable bags,” according to The Gazette.

The bag tax was proposed in March 2011 to encourage residents to use reusable bags and keep plastic bags from littering the environment, however .

For more information on the Montgomery County bag tax’s first month, read The Gazette’s full report.

Have you softened your stance on the bag tax or do you still strongly oppose it? Tell us in the comments!

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from North Potomac-Darnestown Patch? Find your Local Patch »

MocoLoco March 6, 2012 at 01:38 pm
jag & Nearby--what do you think about newspaper bags that hang in trees or float down the street and into the waters? WHY are those not subject to this fee/tax? It's clearly because the county wanted to buy the media's support of this law.
Richard Levy March 6, 2012 at 01:45 pm
The Bag Tax is just another irritant from Montgomery County who KNOWS we are all so stupid we need the Commissioners to tell us how to carry groceries , how to flush the toilet and when and where to drive and park.
It is just so annoying to purchase an item and pay to place it in a plastic bag. I know that the money will go to nought-it will be placed in a " good" fund and then taken to pay for a Commissioner's car or some other non-useful expenditure. I only wish there was an election tomorrow so I could vote them all out for being so outrageous and controlling but int eh meantime I try NOT to shop where stupidity reigns.
Johnny Lucid March 6, 2012 at 02:15 pm
I think the littering laws should be strenously enforced.
I think the bag tax should be repealed. The penny per bag the retailers get to keep seems more like it's to pay them off to endure the complaints of customers inconvenienced by the bag tax. I'm wondering when the administrative and enforcement costs will outstrip the proceeds from the bag tax. I'm confident that it will then become a permanent line item in the County operating budget. I hope County Exec Leggett will fill us in on that.
Andrea Armstrong March 6, 2012 at 04:33 pm
Amen to Woodside Park Bob's thoughtful and dead-on commentary!!!
Anemic March 6, 2012 at 04:37 pm
I haven’t yet softened my stand against any so called “bag” tax and I don’t think I ever will! As I read the review of the revenues this tax has reaped I wonder if the same couldn’t be said if the tax were on our blood cells. You know, tax people’s blood cells! We’ve got so many, imagine what the first month’s revenues might be. Of course there will be an adjustment period for some that eventually will accept it, and some people may never be able to adjust to it, BUT just think of the revenue! If revenue were the only justification necessary for a tax then taxing blood cells is not only ingenious, the revenue will more than justify it! AND, it might encourage people to donate blood more often – less blood cells to tax!
Ed Murtagh March 6, 2012 at 05:27 pm
that is what I meant by admin fee.
Joanne Williams March 6, 2012 at 05:28 pm
I have not softened my stand on the bag tax. Anybody with half a brain knows that this whole idea is just another "hide in the dark" method of squeezing more money out of the residents. DC was successful at getting it passed and MoCounty followed suit, and now PG is jumping on the wagon. I don't understand why the people of this country have become so lazy and have lost interest in standing up for what they believe in. We let this pass. Don't get surprised when they decided they need some more money to pay for all the salaries and useless spending thats inflating the budget -- next on the list will be making us pay .20 per hour for the air we breathe. And we'll all sit back and complain to ourselves instead of saying enough is enough and fight back!
Ed Murtagh March 6, 2012 at 05:53 pm
Plastic bags and bottles are costing Montgomery County taxpayers millions of dollars each year (and costing PG and DC taxpayes a lot too since much of our trash is washed into their communities). If you want to have that type of life style, fine but don't ask me and the county taxpayers to subsidize your life style. Pay the fee and leave the taxpayers alone.
Fighting Back March 6, 2012 at 05:57 pm
If Montgomery County residents would just stop being so damn lazy and bring their own bags with them when they shop, we would not be throwing our money away like this. Let's not give the county satisfaction out of screwing us over. BRING YOUR OWN BAGS OR SHOP IN ANOTHER COUNTY!!!! When they are not receiving as much revenue, they will abolish it and move on to taxing some other frivilous thing.
Jeff Hawkins March 6, 2012 at 06:45 pm
@Joanne
"I don't understand why the people of this country have become so lazy and have lost interest in standing up for what they believe in. We let this pass." I agree with you Joanne... Remember this in November and vote some of these folks out of office.........afterall........."we did let them in". Show'em the door......
Jeff Hawkins March 6, 2012 at 06:50 pm
@Fighting Back
"When they are not receiving as much revenue, they will abolish it and move on to taxing some other frivilous thing." O'Malley will institute a user fee, revenue enhancement, tariff, excise, levy on those bags that we bring in to the store.
Richard Rice March 6, 2012 at 07:16 pm
Jeff,
I am in total agreement with you! Montgomery County and the State of Md. are taxing this retired soul into the ground even though I do bring my own bag or bags with me for every purchase I make.
jag March 6, 2012 at 07:29 pm
"When they are not receiving as much revenue, they will abolish it"
Except the projections are (and the point of the fee is) for a decrease the number of plastic bags used, just like what has happened in DC.
jag March 6, 2012 at 07:39 pm
Richard,
So how are you being taxed if you bring your own bags? Are you talking about other taxes? Maryland doesn't tax income from Social Security, doesn't apply sales tax to food, medicine etc. On top of the lack of taxes, the county has countless programs to offer free and reduce cost services to seniors. I certainly hope we all do enough to support you. If not, I'd love to hear what else can be done.
Marianne6 March 6, 2012 at 08:09 pm
We live in Bethesda and now go to Northern Virginia to do a lot of our shopping. No bag tax = no worries! I have managed to pay the bag tax once and that was at a retail store. It amazes me that people walk in and out of department stores with clothes, shoes, etc. Who is watching people to make sure they are not shoplifting? Are the residents of Montgomery County going to made liable due to an uprise of thefts in the County? This ridiculous bag tax is going to lead to more significant issues in our future and not just litter in our streets.
Jeff Hawkins March 6, 2012 at 08:17 pm
@Richard
Yeah....it can be tough one. That's why so many of us native Marylanders have to leave when it's time to retire. I'm most likely going that route myself very soon. It's too bad really.... As for some of our more idealistic, partisan, naive and inexperienced :) fellow Marylanders, I would just say to them.....your day will come...
Greg Cohen (Editor) March 6, 2012 at 08:18 pm
To be totally honest, I find it interesting how many people now choose to go outside the county for their shopping. Even more interesting are those who readily admit it's to avoid the bag tax.
Realistically, how much more money are you spending on gas by going out of MoCo to shop than by staying in-county and paying 50 cents for 10 bags (if you even need that many)?
Marianne6 March 6, 2012 at 08:22 pm
I don't know about you, Greg, but from our house in Bethesda to No. VA, it's only about 15 minutes. If we do shopping, dining, etc., we don't waste $ on gas, etc. VA also has 5% tax as opposed to MD with 6%, so on high ticket items we actually pay less. We go outside the County to prove a point, not because we can't afford paying for a bag here or there. It's a ridiculous tax and if we stood our ground and didn't pay the tax perhaps the County would abolish it.
Jeff Hawkins March 6, 2012 at 08:38 pm
@Marianne6
The issue of increased shoplifting is real. I have spoke with people at two different grocery stores and they both said, it's now more of a problem than it was before. One store now has a guy just standing at the entrance to "eyeball" you as you leave. O'Malley will institute a "shoplifting tax" to help off-set this problem....
Jeff Hawkins March 6, 2012 at 08:45 pm
@Greg
I believe for most folks it's the principle of the thing. Our country has a colorful history of fighting against tax's that are perceived to be unjust. This is another one.....
Greg Cohen (Editor) March 6, 2012 at 08:48 pm
Not debating the principle of it, Jeff. Merely looking at it from a dollars standpoint. And from the North Potomac-Darnestown area, you're looking at a minimum 30 minute drive with no traffic to get outside of the county.
Personally, my time is worth more than 5 cents per bag.
jnrentz1 March 6, 2012 at 11:05 pm
Katie,
Should the Montgomery County Council have term limits?
Momof8 March 28, 2012 at 03:15 pm
It never fails that half the time I spontaneously end up going shopping and then also end up carrying way too many groceries, dropping half of them because the bag that I used 'last time' was left in the house after unpacking from a previous trip. I also expect that shop lifting will rise ... how is a retailer to know whether someone paid for something when they're walking around with items out of a bag. Alternatively, it's a whole lot easier for people to shop lift when walking into a store with an empty bag. Is any county authority collecting any data on that, with the associated financial implications? All said, like many others I too am shopping as much as possible now out of the county. This recycling of bags has little to do about helping the consumer, saving the environment ... it's all about more money into the county coffers!
John Jackson April 29, 2012 at 05:58 pm
You are the one asking to subsidize a life style. If you want to carry bags to the shopping mall, go for it. Don't demand that I do the same. Paper bags are bio-degradeable. The tax on bags includes paper bags, something the DC law doesn't even demand. The tax on paper bags has nothing to do with saving rivers and the bay. It is social engineering pure and simple.
Ed Murtagh April 30, 2012 at 06:07 pm
Sorry John, your comments are both baffling and totally wrong. I have never promoted charging a fee for paper bags. My comments have focused on plastic bags and bottles. I had no role in writing the bag laws, but I assume you can thank your plastic bag manufacturing friends for the inclusion of paper bags. Your statement about DC’s bag law is both irrelevant and incorrect. DC does charge a fee for paper bags (other than crryout food bags). See DC website:. http://green.dc.gov/service/skip-bag-save-river The rest of your comments are equally misinformed and will not waste any time commenting on them.
lilkunta May 24, 2012 at 04:13 am
reusable bags called norovirus outbreak in oregon:
http://maximumnewsinformer.com/?p=7473
Billy Bob August 10, 2012 at 04:10 pm
I'm just visiting MoCo. When I was told about the bag tax as I was buying a some drinks, I said to myself "what idiots they are in Maryland." This kind of tax would not be accepted in my part of the country (southeastern NC). Why do you stand for it? Vote the idiots out.
Billy Bob August 10, 2012 at 04:19 pm
....and when I got back to my hotel, I was told that I could only receive two "free" glasses of beer because the county/state(?) would tax anything more than 2 drinks....something about increasing the value of the stay...therefore more taxes on the increased value....lol...are you kidding me?
jag August 10, 2012 at 04:21 pm
If people didn't wrap plastic bottles in plastic and then stick them in plastic bags without giving it any thought then there wouldn't need to be a nickle tax to make you think twice and realize how stupid and unnecessary it is. The fact the rural south wouldn't "accept" the notion of intelligent usage says a lot, but probably not what you think it does.
Ed Murtagh August 10, 2012 at 04:35 pm
Billy Bob,
Since you are not from around here, a little background. Plastic litter is part of a multi-million dollar problem in Montgomery County. Example, cleaning out a storm drain that is in part clogged by plastic bags in very expensive. Before the bag fee, taxpayers picked up the tab. I these hard economic times, that is ludicrous. Now users of disposable bags pick up the tab. The result? A big drop in the use of plastic bags. I was at an electronic store not too long ago. Everyone in line had some sort of purchase that could easily be taken out. Instead of automatically putting the purchases in the bag, the cashier now asks do you want a bag. Do you know what happened at that store? Every customer said “no”, I don’t need a bag for the purchase. Perhaps in southeastern NC this is not an issue or that taxpayers simply pick up the tab without question. It is too soon to tell right now, but I assume there will be a significant decrease in the cost of addressing litter so everyone will come out on top.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something